I am interested to know whether you subscribe to the idea of an essential self – do we have a unique individual essence or are we made up by the flows of words, concepts and practice that complicate our present time?

Sincerely Stephen

Philosopher's reply

Dear Stephen,

Neither! I am this human animal, feeling the sun on her face, and the desk edge on her forearms – and who will one of these days be dead. But what it takes for us to ask the question ‘what am I?’ tends to get mixed up with the answer. I hope that this does not come as a deflating – depressing – reply. I don’t think it should: humans run deep and we unearth things – sweet, shocking, sad – about who we are, and how we work, if not what we are – all the time.

This might seem like an answer we would have given as children – but given our current capacities to reflect on death, change, and what seems possible, it takes a lot of philosophy to regain it and understand what it means for us.

Lucy O’Brien

Philosopher's profile

Lucy O'Brien


Philosophy is really looking.

Lucy O’Brien

How would you answer this question?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *